Home
About the BGA
Join Us
Investigations
Watchdog Training
BGA Policies
Public Resources
Media
Contact Us
   

Join Our Mailing List
Workers Give to Stroger's Campaign, Get Big Raises
Patronage workers give to Stroger's campaign fund, get big raises
BGA / Sun-Times Investigation
August 24, 2009

Patronage workers with the Cook County Forest Preserve District are seeing more green these days -- in their paychecks.

With people everywhere facing tough financial times, the 28 forest preserve patronage workers who've been on the payroll since 2006 all got hefty raises in the following two years, an analysis by the Chicago Sun-Times and the Better Government Association has found. They're among 38 forest preserve workers who are exempt from the Shakman court order that bans political hiring in city and county government.

On average, the exempt employees were paid $98,071 last year. Nine of them saw their salaries increase 19 percent or more between 2006 and 2008.

Most of the Shakman-exempt employees -- 24 in all -- have contributed to the campaign funds of Cook County Board President Todd Stroger; his late father, former board President John Stroger; or the 8th Ward Regular Democratic Organization that John Stroger controlled.

The Strogers and the party organization have gotten a total of $49,870 in campaign contributions from the exempt employees since the mid-1990s. The biggest contributor: Deputy Comptroller Alvin Lee ($12,100), followed by district police chief Richard Waszak ($8,050).

That's their right, says district spokesman Steve Mayberry, who says Todd Stroger never has solicited forest preserve employees for campaign cash.

"It is the First Amendment right of all private citizens ... to make political contributions to whomever they please," says Mayberry, himself a Shakman-exempt employee who has given $3,905 to Stroger organizations.

The number of exempt employees amounts to less than 7 percent of the district's 564-person work force.

"The current Shakman-exempt list is a result of long and careful debate," Mayberry says. "It is intended to recognize the need for the president of Cook County and the Forest Preserve District of Cook County to have some confidential employees in leadership positions."

The Forest Preserve District is separate from county government -- even though it's overseen by the same president and commissioners. A judge has assigned the district its own Shakman compliance administrator, Jan Carlson, who says district officials have asked to add "four or five new" exempt positions. Carlson is reviewing those requests.

Many of those with Shakman-exempt jobs with the district have an 8th Ward pedigree, but not all. Among those:

• The district's top executive, Steve Bylina, has worked in Ald. Edward M. Burke's 14th Ward organization. A forestry expert, his annual pay is $168,511.

• Former county commissioner and 37th Ward Ald. Frank Damato is the district's "coordinator of community intergovernmental relations." He makes $100,657.

• Frank Mole, who has ties to the 36th Ward Regular Democratic organization, holds the title "assistant maintenance superintendent III." His salary went from $82,844 in 2006 to $99,686 in 2008 -- a 20 percent hike.

• Vito Benigno, who was active in former 42nd Ward Ald. Burton Natarus' Democratic organization, is a "recreation superintendent III." His pay rose 22 percent from 2006 to 2008, to $105,851.

In all, 28 of the Shakman-exempt forest preserve workers saw their pay rise 13 percent or more during the three-year period. The only Shakman-exempt staffers who got pay hikes of less than 13 percent were the 10 who had been in their jobs for two years or less.

Mayberry says the raises resulted, in part, from the district's approving a new contract for unionized employees in December 2007 that "included wage increases that were, at that time, primarily retroactive.

"As is accepted and common practice among local and state governments, these increases were extended to all district employees" except forest preserve police officers, who were covered by a different contract, Mayberry says. The County Board approved similar wage hikes for county workers. (Go to suntimes.com/ news/watchdogs for details.)

In addition, Stroger "may" grant additional raises for nonunion employees without having them undergo evaluations, "though that's a very rare occurrence," Mayberry says. The forest preserves, he adds, are "developing a comprehensive and fair performance evaluation system, which should be rolled out to all employees" by November.

Forest Preserve patronage pay

Here's how salaries have grown from 2006 to 2008 for the 38 Shakman-exempt employees of the Cook County Forest Preserve District. Every one of them who was with the district in a Shakman-exempt post in 2006 got a double-digit salary increase by 2008. Twenty-four of the patronage workers (marked with an *) have contributed to the campaign funds of Cook County Board President Todd Stroger; his late father, former board President John Stroger, or the 8th Ward Regular Democratic Organization that John Stroger controlled.

Employee 2006 2007 2008 % change '06 to '08
Steve Bylina, general superintendent* $148,531 $164,002 $168,511 13%
Dennis A. White, chief attorney* NA $137,923 $144,550 5%
Marlo V. Kemp, chief financial officer* NA $128,444 $131,976 3%
Lauren W. Gore, assistant chief attorney* $98,713 $106,858 $111,993 13%
William Helm, executive assistant to gen'l. supt.* NA $108,913 $111,908 3%
Daniel P. Donovan, comptroller $98,376 $108,624 $111,611 13%
Leroy Taylor, maintenance superintendent III* $98,376 $108,624 $111,611 13%
Vito Benigno, recreation superintendent III $86,549 $103,018 $105,851 22%
Richard Newhard, director of resource management $88,720 $99,778 $105,851 19%
Thomas J. Conlon, purchasing agent* NA $102,688 $105,512 3%
Richard Waszak, police chief* $92,695 $92,695 $105,165 13%
Susan Salita, asst. to gen'l. superintendent for labor $91,451 $98,998 $103,755 13%
Carmen Sanchez, director of human resources* NA $100,526 $103,291 3%
Allan Mellis, director of planning and development $88,791 $96,117 $100,734 13%
Frank Damato, coord., community intergov. relations* $88,720 $97,962 $100,657 13%
Richard Bono, assistant maintenance superintendent III* $82,457 $91,474 $98,688 20%
Frank Mole, assistant maintenance superintendent III $82,844 $96,047 $99,686 20%
Joseph T. Bishop, admin. asst. to gen'l. superintendent* $87,868 $97,020 $99,686 13%
Chris Merenowicz, asst. director, resource management $83,685 $93,323 $95,888 15%
Mary Gardner, secretary, board of commissioners* $83,685 $92,400 $94,942 13%
Eugene Gallagher, regional superintendent II* $77,060 $91,046 $93,989 22%
Alvin Lee, deputy comptroller* $82,457 $91,046 $93,989 14%
Cathy Geraghty, director of grant development $82,457 $91,046 $93,550 13%
Samuel J. Simone, admin. asst. to gen'l. superintendent $82,457 $91,046 $93,550 13%
John Palcu III, assistant police chief* NA NA $92,478 NA
Eddie L. McCann Jr., first deputy police chief* $77,320 $79,321 $92,475 20%
Steve Mayberry, information representative IV* $75,202 $83,411 $85,704 14%
Eloise Saperstein, special events coordinator $75,202 $83,036 $85,704 14%
Daniel Varello, deputy police chief NA $77,320 $85,374 10%
Rickey Green, assistant recreation superintendent* $75,202 $83,036 $85,317 13%
Michael E. Martin, regional superintendent* $71,679 $83,036 $85,317 19%
Darrell J. Howell, regional superintendent* NA $79,146 $81,322 3%
Jose Virella, regional superintendent* $68,424 $79,146 $81,322 19%
Tracy McIntyre, executive secretary $68,424 $75,552 $78,033 14%
Tom W. Sharpe, management analyst IV* $68,424 $75,945 $78,033 14%
Christopher S. Adas, real estate agent III NA NA $77,630 NA
Ward Wayman, administrative assistant V $62,329 $72,076 $77,630 25%
Derick Cornelius, internal auditor NA $49,581 $53,408 8%

Visit the BGA Payroll Database

Save The Date Visit the BGA Payroll Database