Fact-Check: Casten Overblows Heat Wave Claim to Support More Action on Climate Change
Among them was U.S. Rep. Sean Casten, a former clean-energy entrepreneur who represents Illinois’ west suburban 6th Congressional District. To make his point, the second-term congressman gave a local example to emphasize the cost of a rapidly warming world.
“Chicago had a heat wave in 1995 that killed 739 people,” Casten said Aug. 23. “Prior to 9/11 that was the largest single-day, non-war fatality in the United States. We are now expecting temperatures that hot in Chicago every summer.”
The #IPCCReport makes it clear this is our last chance to take the #ClimateAction science demands.— Rep. Sean Casten (@RepCasten) August 24, 2021
I joined @USRepKCastor, @RepDebDingell, & @RepHorsford for a press conference hosted by @LCVoters, @actonclimateUS & @BGAlliance because have to act. Now. pic.twitter.com/Ep7QDHJkv9
The heat wave that struck Chicago that July more than 25 years ago was labeled the deadliest weather event in the city’s history. But it did not take those lives in a single day, making it impossible to compare the tragedy to more sudden disasters. Casten is on firmer ground when it comes to predictions about forecasts for more frequent extreme heat in Chicago, though he left out some important context there, too.
Not a ‘single-day’ disaster
While the event is considered among the nation’s deadliest climate disasters, it was not the deadliest domestic tragedy prior to the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, nor the most fatal event in Chicago history. In 1915, for instance, a passenger boat called the SS Eastland capsized while tied to a dock in the Chicago River, killing 844.
Casten specified “single-day” fatalities, so we wondered why he chose to compare an estimated death toll for a heat wave that spanned multiple days to the number of fatalities from more sudden disasters like the SS Eastland sinking.
In response to our question, Casten spokesperson Emilia Rowland acknowledged the mistake. “I believe my boss misspoke,” she wrote in an email.
Research forecasts more frequent extreme heat — but not before 2050, and not necessarily every year
As backup for the second part of Casten’s claim, Rowland sent us a 2010 research brief from the University of Illinois that explored what the Midwest’s climate may look like by mid-century.
During the deadly 1995 Chicago heat wave, the two-page publication notes, “temperatures soared as high as 106 degrees during the day and stayed above 80 degrees on many of the hottest nights. Such heat waves will be more commonplace in 2050. Under lower emissions scenarios, they could occur once per decade. Under higher emissions scenarios, they could happen once a year.”
Those predictions were based on previous work from the climate scientists who authored the brief, Donald Wuebbles of the University of Illinois and Katharine Hayhoe of Texas Tech University. The future looks even more grim by the end of the century, when their research predicts Chicago could see 1995-like heat waves every other year even if emissions are lowered and up to three times per year if emissions are not significantly reduced soon.
But the research doesn’t fully back up Casten’s claim that Chicago is “now expecting” temperatures as hot as the 1995 heat wave every summer.
“We are expecting temperatures as hot as the 1995 heat wave in Chicago to recur more frequently as a result of climate change: that is absolutely true,” Hayhoe said. “The question is, ‘how often?’ — and that depends both on the time frame we’re talking about, and even more critically on our emission choices.”
Casten said the 1995 Chicago heat wave that killed 739 people was “the largest single-day, non-war fatality in the United States” prior to 9/11 and “we are now expecting temperatures that hot in Chicago every summer.”
That heat wave spanned multiple days, making it impossible to compare the event to more sudden tragedies, many of which also killed more people. Casten’s office told us the congressman was mistaken in this comparison.
Casten is correct that Chicago faces a future of increasingly frequent extreme heat. If significant actions are not taken to reduce emissions, the city could face 1995-like heat waves every year. But Chicago might still avoid this fate with lower emissions, researchers said, and even in the worst case such extreme heat events would not become so frequent until at least 2050.
We rate Casten’s claim Mostly False.
MOSTLY FALSE – The statement contains an element of truth but ignores critical facts that would give a different impression.
Click here for more on the six PolitiFact ratings and how we select facts to check.
Press conference, C-SPAN, Aug. 23, 2021
“Chicago’s Deadly 1995 Heat Wave: An Oral History,” Chicago Magazine, June 29, 2015
Mortality in Chicago Attributed to the July 1995 Heat Wave, American Journal of Public Health, September 1997
“Chicago Learned Climate Lessons from Its Deadly 1995 Heat Wave,” Scientific American, July 16, 2020
Email, Casten spokesperson Emilia Rowland, Aug. 25, 2021
“What will the climate be like in 2050?” University of Illinois, 2010
Climate change, heat waves, and mortality projections for Chicago, Journal of Great Lakes Research, Aug. 21, 2009
Email: Donald Wuebbles, professor of atmospheric science at the University of Illinois, Aug. 25-27, 2021
Email: Katharine Hayhoe, chief scientist for The Nature Conservancy and professor of political science at Texas Tech University, Aug. 27, 2021
Assessment of the Impacts of Climate Change in Illinois, The Nature Conservancy, 2021
Climate Action Plan for the Chicago Region, Metropolitan Mayors Caucus and NOAA, 2021